Posts

Showing posts from December, 2008

Establishing a Tribunal for Mumbai Suspects

Although a war between India and Pakistan is unlikely in the near future, both nations are exchanging muted threats of war veiled in the right of self-defense. Rumors abound that India is considering surgical strikes on terrorist hideouts in Pakistan to send a strong message to anti-India militants and to warn Pakistani intelligence agencies that India would no longer accept terrorist attacks on its soil. India has also asked Pakistan to extradite the top leaders of Lashkar-i-Taiba and Jammat- ud- Da'wah, the militant organizations allegedly involved in the planning of Mumbai attacks. Both courses of action ---- Read More

Scholarship an Act of Discovery

All scholarship is an act of discovery. One may read, read, and read cases and statutes and legal literature to generate one's own piece of scholarship. But research, though necessary, does not produce durable scholarship. Lasting scholarship is like discovering penicillin. It is like capturing a fleeting revelation. It is an experience reported in language. True legal scholarship is researched poetry of the highest order. Rumi, Frost, Keats would have been great legal scholars. Legal schoalrship as an act of discovery is also compatible with Islamic law, that is, the law of the Quran and the Prophet's Sunnah. " Quran is the Scripture that We have revealed unto thee, full of blessing, that they may ponder its revelations, and that persons of understanding may reflect. " This invitation to understanding through reflection is an act of dicovery. (Click and download this article that might benefit new professors who are striving to make their scholarship float in the oce...

Speech Divesity under Islamic Law

In order to further clarify the grammar of speech diversity, the Basic Code intimates that the diversity of nations and communities is also part of the divine plan. The Quran states: “O human beings! Lo! We have created you male and female and have made you nations and tribes that you may know one another (ta’aaraf).”This solidarity ordainment recognizes two distinct diversities, gender and communal, which are mentioned together in the same verse to demonstrate their analogous rooting in natural law. Gender identity furnishes self-knowledge whereas communal identity supplies familiarity with others. Each identity, such as sisterhood or brotherhood derived from gender and camaraderie derived from meta-gender community, is both natural and authentic. It is natural for women to congregate with women and men with men, for such congregations furnish gender-specific knowledge. However, men and women cannot be imprisoned in their respective genders. Men and women must meaningfully and respec...

Mumbai and the Kashmir Tinderbox

The Mumbai massacre is a heinous crime, allegedly carried out by Lashkar-e-Tiaba (Army of the Pure), a militant organization that is fighting for liberation of Indian-occupied Kashmir. Formed in the days when liberation movements enjoyed legitimacy under international law, Lashkar has been outlawed since 2002 as a terrorist organization in Pakistan, India, the United States, and several other countries. The post-9/11 war on terror has further weakened the liberation movement for Kashmir. Under pressure from the United States, Pakistan has withdrawn its moral and military support from militant groups that have been training for decades to liberate Kashmir. The Mumbai massacre is a sad reminder, however, that the unresolved Kashmir dispute is the tinderbox of South Asia. Origin of the Kashmir Dispute In 1947, British India was partitioned between Muslims and Hindus. The law of partition, however, did not settle the future of more than five hundred semi-independent princely states, includ...